The Modesty of the Proud Scotsman

Can heritage determine a person’s personal values?

Parents or guardians tend to be the ones largely responsible for modeling behavior and instilling values—good or bad—in their children. Certainly other family members, education, religion, politics, popular culture, and where one resides can also be influences.

Those factors are best described as “nurture.” But does genetics—“nature”—in any way shape one’s values?

I don’t think anyone can definitively answer that question. Certainly, taken too far, making assumptions about another’s behavior based upon his or her genetic makeup or ethnicity starts getting into the dangerous territory of racial profiling and stereotypes. But it is an interesting theoretical question: what if any role does the culture from which one descends play in the prioritization of specific values or behavior across multiple generations of a family?

I was thinking about this question as I grappled with writing about an ancestor who would seem to “embody what’s important to [my] family.”

What first came to mind was my father’s maternal lineage and what seems to me to be a common character trait. There exists in this branch of the family a pattern of personal modesty and a reticence to draw attention to oneself.

Could our Scottish heritage have something to do with our sharing this specific trait?

My great-grandfather was the youngest of six children and the only person in his family to have been born in America. Before he was born, his parents and siblings—all born in Scotland—had immigrated to America.

The Williamson family not long after coming to America.
My great-grandfather is the toddler.

I remember visits to see my great-grandfather, his son—my great uncle—and my grandmother. My recollections are of the adults sitting comfortably on the porch or in the living room. There were often long silences during which the rustling of the wind in the trees or the quiet ticking of a mantel clock could be heard. But these lapses in conversation never felt awkward.

I think that, as a young child, I assumed these lulls were due to the fact that these relatives were elderly and their thoughts came and words formed more slowly. And that could have been a plausible explanation for why these relatives interacted in a leisurely, soft-spoken way.

But years later, I wonder if some of those comfortable, unhurried silences happened because those assembled were loathe to talk about themselves.

I do not remember any of the members of this family talking at length about themselves. Or talking at length at all, for that matter. Questions were asked, but rarely was there a lengthy, detailed explanation in response, nor was there typically any lengthy preamble involved in relating stories.

These were people of few words.

This was in contrast to visits to see my mother’s parents and family. Conversations were louder, livelier. My maternal grandmother tended to talk at length, her stories often necessitating additional explanation to “set the stage” for the story she was in the process of telling. And often one story led directly into another.

There were few lulls in the conversation. Any silences that did occur were usually filled with the sound of the television which was on almost constantly while we were there, usually showing sports or something else of little interest to me.

I would not characterize visits to my mother’s parents’ house as uncomfortable. Rather, I would say that, for the most part, there existed a completely different energy in the two households.


My paternal grandmother’s lineage traces directly back to Scotland as does that of my maternal grandmother, albeit by way of Ireland. My two grandfathers’ roots go back to England and to Germany. Obviously, I am a genetic composite of their collective DNA, but my ethnicity has been determined to be predominately Scottish.


I was curious to see what Scottish proverbs I might find on the subject of modesty. I found quite a few:

The number of Scottish proverbs on modesty suggest that arrogance and boastfulness have been frowned upon in that culture for generations.

But if asked today, would someone living in Scotland say that immodesty and boastfulness are still highly frowned upon in the culture?

From “A Study of the Scots,” by Scotsman Neil Robertson:

…there’s the issue of modesty. We like acknowledgement of our gallant efforts at being a good Scot sure (pat on the head), but are usually uncomfortable with direct praise. We can’t exit the conversation fast enough if that materialises. Gruff, monosyllabic small talk and desperate references to the weather or the Cowdenbeath football score can be expected instead.

The Glaswegian-born mother, Sue, of the mother-daughter duo behind the blog Scottish at Heart lists one of the “Characteristics of Scottish People” as “Polite but reserved, until we get to know you.”


I admit that being in the company of someone talking incessantly about himself or herself does make me very uncomfortable. I don’t remember if I was cautioned by my parents that doing so was pretentious or whether lessons of humility were instead implicit and absorbed by observation.

The possibility of genetics playing a role in a family’s values is interesting to contemplate, at least. Today’s DNA tests even include data listing one’s predisposition toward certain tendencies based upon those results. I do not place a lot of faith in those generalities, though, just based upon my own results.

Of the more than 100+ supposed traits and tendencies analyzed using my DNA, here are a few results that are decidedly inaccurate:

Actually, I started piano lessons at age 6, started on saxophone in 5th grade and oboe in 8th grade. I played the oboe professionally for almost 40 years.
In reality, I’m a heavy coffee drinker and find it difficult to limit myself to three cups a day!
Once again, not true: I grew up having dogs, and ever since living in an apartment that allowed them and then owning a home, I’ve always had pets.

In all fairness, the assessment was fairly accurate with regard to other behavioral traits, and it was dead-on with many physical attributes such as blue eyes and thin hair that’s light in color.

Although there is science behind some of this information, a lot of the traits are mostly speculative. Coffee consumption, pet ownership, and similar “traits” seem to me more likely to be the product of one’s upbringing: nurture. To me, reading results more related to behavior or personal choice is akin to reading one’s astrological forecast: it’s amusing—and some of it might seem to actually correlate—but it is ultimately conjecture.


So does genetics play any role in human behavior? According to Dr. Brenda Shook, a better question would be, “To what extent is a particular behavior genetic or learned?” Arriving at an answer is complicated if not impossible.

Here is a summation of an interesting article posted by the Editorial Board of National University about studies conducted in this field:

Human behavior is both genetic and learned, the nature versus nurture debate has been resolved by modern science not as a contest but as a continuous interaction, where genetics provide biological predispositions and environment shapes how those predispositions are expressed. Twin and adoption studies, the most rigorous design for separating genetic from environmental influences, consistently find that genetics account for approximately 30% to 60% of variation in personality traits, intelligence, and behavioral tendencies, with the remaining variation attributable to environmental factors including family, culture, education, and life experience.

I think it’s safe to say that the substance of who each of us are—our essence—is a distillation of many things, one of which is our ancestors. Or, put more poetically,

Every man is a quotation from all his ancestors.”  -Ralph Waldo Emerson

Written for the 52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks Challenge: Week 45-“A Family Value.” Love, family, honesty, charity – these are just a few words that describe family values. Who is someone that seems to embody what’s important to your family? Of course, feel free to interpret this prompt however you’d like.

Leave a Reply